Seven Football Manager Challenges that Only Masochists & Psychopaths Attempt

If you love a Football Manager challenge, then this is the place for you. Following on from our most cursed saves in FM26 piece, we now bring you another round of brutal challenges if you’re feeling up to it.

Most Football Manager saves are built around comfort. You find a tactic that works, you sign a few wonderkids, you tweak things when results dip, and eventually you’re lifting trophies while wondering why the game suddenly feels easy after about five years. These challenges are the opposite of that. They remove safety nets, punish bad luck, and actively fight against how most people play FM. They’re not designed to be fun in the traditional sense. They’re designed to see how deep your understanding of the game actually goes, and how much suffering you’re willing to tolerate along the way. If you’re looking for a relaxed save, stop reading now.

 

1. The youth-intake-only pentagon challenge.

Win the continental Champions League on all five continents using only players generated by your own youth intake at each club. No signings. No loans. No free agents. Nothing. very squad you build must come entirely from the academy.

Why it’s brutal:

You’re completely at the mercy of youth quality, facilities and national reputation. And you have to do this in every continent, where for a lot of teams, their youth facilities are not particularly good. Africa, Asia and North America do not care about your long-term plans when your intake spits out five full-backs and a goalkeeper with no hands.

 

2. The zero transfers save

You are never allowed to sign a player. Not permanently. Not on loan. Not even on a free. You may only use:
Players already at the club
Youth intakes
That’s it.

Why it’s brutal:

One bad intake can ruin multiple seasons. Promotion often makes your squad worse overnight, and relegation battles become unavoidable. You quickly realise how reliant most saves are on the transfer market to paper over cracks.

 

 

3. The no attributes challenge

You are not allowed to view any player’s attributes. Ever. You have to turn on attribute masking.

You may only use:

• Player reports
• Pure in-game statistics
• Personality descriptions
• Match performances
• Body language

Why it’s brutal:

This strips Football Manager back to vibes, judgement and statistical analysis. In reality, it’s how the football is in real life if you think about it. You’ll second-guess every decision, misjudge players constantly, and discover very quickly whether you understand football, or just an expert in attributes.

 

 

4. The one-nation squad, foreign league save

Manage in a top league, but you may only sign players from one single nationality that does not match the league.

Examples:

• Japanese players in Serie A
• Colombian players in the Bundesliga

Why it’s brutal:

Registration rules hate you. Language barriers ruin cohesion. The talent pool dries up quickly. And when your one elite player wants to leave, there is no replacement waiting in the wings.

 

 

5. The catenaccio/park-the-bus only challenge

FM26 finally made counter-attacking football viable again. Gegenpress and vertical tiki-taka make life easier than ever. Now forget all of that. Your task is to win the Champions League using only deep defensive, low-block systems and direct passing. No pressing madness. No high lines. Just disciplined suffering.

Why it’s brutal:

These styles are unforgiving, difficult to balance, and brutally exposed against elite opposition. I’ve tried it. It went badly. Winning Europe like this feels borderline impossible, which is exactly the point.

 

 

6. The homegrown-only Champions League

Win the Champions League using a squad where every registered player is homegrown at club.

Not:

• Homegrown in nation
• Signed at 18
• Only players developed by your academy.

Why it’s brutal:

Squad depth becomes a nightmare. Injuries can kill entire seasons. One weak intake can set you back five years. Rotating for Europe while staying compliant with registration rules is genuinely horrific.

 

 

7. The time-limit glory challenge

You have 10 seasons to:

• Start in the bottom tier
• Reach the top division
• Win a continental trophy

Miss the deadline and the save is over. No excuses.

Why it’s brutal:

There’s no room for “one more rebuild year”. Every season matters. One failed promotion push or a bad year of recruitment can completely kill the challenge before you even realise you’re behind schedule.These aren’t challenges you dip into casually. They’re slow, punishing and often deeply unfair. But if you want to prove you’ve mastered Football Manager, not just beaten it, this is where you find out how much pain you’re actually willing to endure. Good luck, soldier.

 

 

Make sure you check out our Feature Articles section for more great FM26 updates and tips.